How can I lower my home insurance costs? Shop around. According to Intercontinental Exchange, homeowners who switched insurers saw premiums drop 6.6% on average, about $440 a year, while those who stayed saw a 10.4% increase.

When you're planning a move, every monthly cost counts. Home insurance has been creeping up, and it now makes up 9.6% of the average monthly mortgage payment, according to Intercontinental Exchange (ICE).

The good news: those increases are starting to slow. Here's what you need to know, and what you can do about it.

Premiums Are Rising More Slowly

In mid-2024, home insurance premiums rose 4.3% in a single quarter. By the second quarter of this year, that was down to 1.8%, the smallest quarterly increase in almost three years.

ICE's Andy Walden notes that insurance has been one of the fastest-growing parts of the monthly payment, but the pace is finally easing.

Your premium will likely still rise over time. It just may not climb as fast as it did a couple of years ago.

Shopping Around Pays Off

This is where you have some control. According to ICE:

  • Homeowners who switched insurers saw premiums drop 6.6% on average.

  • Homeowners who stayed put saw premiums rise 10.4%.

That's about $440 a year in savings for those who switched. And they didn't give up coverage to get it. Their deductibles dipped 1.4%, and their coverage limits rose 7.3%.

The same idea applies if you're buying:

  • Get multiple quotes before you choose a provider.

  • Review your policy every year at renewal.

  • Don't assume the first price is the best price.

A San Diego Note: Start Early

In San Diego County, insurance can vary a lot depending on location, especially in areas with higher wildfire risk. Coverage options and costs can differ from one neighborhood to the next.

If you're buying, start getting insurance quotes early in escrow, not the week before closing. Knowing your insurance cost up front gives you a clearer picture of your true monthly payment.

This ties right back to my three pillars: location, condition, and price. Location can affect your premium, and a home's condition, like the age of the roof and systems, can too.

The Home You Choose Matters

According to John Burns Research and Consulting, newly built homes are 10% to 15% less expensive to insure than older homes nationally.

A new home isn't the right fit for every buyer. But if you're open to one, it could be one more way to keep monthly costs down.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much can I save by switching home insurance?

According to ICE, homeowners who switched saved about $440 a year on average, with a 6.6% drop in premiums.

Is home insurance more expensive in San Diego?

It depends on the location and the home. Wildfire risk, the home's age, and its condition can all affect cost and availability. Get quotes early.

Are new homes cheaper to insure?

Generally, yes. Newly built homes are 10% to 15% less expensive to insure than older homes nationally, according to John Burns Research and Consulting.

Plan Ahead

Home insurance is a bigger part of the monthly payment than it used to be. But you have ways to keep it in check: compare options before you buy, review your policy every year, and lean on trusted local professionals.

If you're planning a move in San Diego County, call or text me. I'm happy to help you plan for the full cost of homeownership and connect you with the right people.

Billie Bourgeois | REALTOR® Real Broker | San Diego County, CA DRE# 01703336