Is a rate buydown better than a price cut? Often, yes, if the buyer cares most about the monthly payment. The same seller concession put toward a buydown can lower a buyer's monthly payment several times more than the same amount taken off the price.

More sellers are cutting prices, especially when their home has been on the market a while without offers. According to HousingWire Data, about 43% of sellers have reduced their price, the highest share in four years.

But there may be a better option for your bottom line, and one buyers find just as appealing: a rate buydown.

Why Buyers Expect a Deal

In September, Redfin reported 63% more sellers than buyers in the market. With that many options, buyers know they have leverage. And with rates squeezing their budgets, they're using it.

The most common ask is price. Buyers want to feel like they're getting a deal, and they want a lower monthly payment. Since they can't control rates, price feels like the obvious lever.

But being flexible doesn't always mean lowering your price.

What Is a Rate Buydown?

A buydown is money paid at closing to lower the buyer's mortgage rate. When you pay it as the seller, you're prepaying some of the buyer's interest, so they get a lower rate and a lower payment.

  • Temporary buydown: Lowers the rate for the first year or two, then it returns to the full rate. A good fit for buyers who expect to refinance.

  • Permanent buydown: Lowers the rate for the life of the loan, paid with discount points. One point costs 1% of the loan and, according to FICO, typically lowers the rate by about a quarter of a percent. A good fit for buyers who plan to stay long term.

Same Money, Different Results

Here's an example at San Diego price points. Say you're willing to make a $25,000 concession, and your buyer has a $1 million, 30-year fixed loan at 7%. Their payment is about $6,650 a month (principal and interest).

  • Cut the price $25,000: The payment drops about $166 a month.

  • 2-1 temporary buydown (about $23,000): The payment drops about $1,285 a month in year one and about $658 in year two.

  • Permanent buydown (about 2.5 points): The rate drops to about 6.4%, saving roughly $414 a month for the life of the loan.

Same concession. But the 2-1 buydown saves the buyer nearly eight times more each month in the first year than the price cut does. And since most buyers shop by monthly payment, that's what gets their attention.

These figures are estimates for illustration. Actual costs and savings depend on the loan, the lender, and the market. Your buyer's lender can run exact numbers.

Things to Know

  • Loan programs cap seller concessions. There's a limit to how much you can contribute toward a buyer's costs.

  • A buydown doesn't end negotiations. Buyers may still ask for repairs or other credits.

  • Advertise it. Mentioning a buydown in your listing lets agents and buyers know it's available.

  • Run the numbers in advance. I can model buydowns and your other selling costs ahead of time, so you're ready when an offer comes in.

NAR Chief Economist Lawrence Yun has said sellers need to be realistic about local conditions, which may call for price discounts or other incentives.

It still comes back to my three pillars: location, condition, and price. A buydown doesn't replace the right price or a home that shows well. It's one more tool to help the right buyer say yes.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a seller pay for a buyer's rate buydown?

Yes. A seller can contribute toward a buydown as a concession at closing, within the limits of the buyer's loan program.

What is a 2-1 buydown?

A temporary buydown that lowers the rate 2% in year one and 1% in year two before returning to the full rate.

Should I cut my price or offer a buydown?

It depends on your buyer and your home. If the buyer is focused on the monthly payment, a buydown can go further than the same amount off the price.

Let's Compare Your Options

A price reduction isn't your only option. A rate buydown can save your buyer more each month while protecting your bottom line. If you're selling in San Diego County, call or text me and let's run the numbers on which incentive makes the biggest difference for your home.

Billie Bourgeois | REALTOR® Real Broker | San Diego County, CA DRE# 01703336